I love comments.  So leave me lots! :)


Sign Guestbook   Back to petra carden   Report abuse

NameTimberly
Date2007-07-11
MessageI like history too, but I think LeRoy will oust me from the house if I join another book club smilie I am reading an interesting book about Scottish history around the time of the 1700s, interesting where things started.
Report

Nameti
Date2007-07-11
Messagei've never read the harry potter books, did start watching a movie once, but turned it off after about 15 minutes. the reason why is that is simply doesn't interest me.

i do like the movie 'constantine' and have it on dvd.

personally, i prefer reading history. i belong to the history book club (if anyone wants to join let me refer you and get a free book!) smilie
Report

NamePetra
Date2007-07-11
MessageGreat comments so far. Anyone else? smilie

p.s. I also thank you all for your politeness to one another. smilie
Report

NameTrish
Date2007-07-11
MessageI agree with Emily. There have been a lot of good thought provoking post. I look forward to reading more. Interesting subject.
Report

NameEmily
Date2007-07-11
MessageI would like to add how very much I appreciate everyones COURTESY on their posts! It is really nice to read other people's viewpoints without feeling like I've been "virtually" yelled at. Thank you all.
Report

NameDaniel
Date2007-07-11
Locationclick picture for more information
MessageGood post. We haven't read the books, but we have seen some of the movies. Thinking in the context of just Michelle and me, the movies were mildly entertaining but mostly they were a waste of our time. Neither of us felt drawn to witchcraft by them, and I think that Andrea makes a good point that if one says, "No witchcraft allowed in our media," then that should be applied across the board, even in cases where the witchcraft is defeated by good. (Of course, the Bible has stories of demon-possessed people and practitioners of witchcraft, so I don't think it is wrong to read a story or watch a movie that contains witchcraft; the key is as Petra indicates - the witchcraft should be seen as evil, which LOTR doesn't do because there is good witchcraft vs. bad witchcraft; but, then again, there is good spiritual warfare vs. bad spiritual warfare in our lives, meaning evil people have Satan and demons on their side, and Christians have angels and the Trinity on their side, so. . .) I don't think I'd let my children watch or read HP not so much because it's going to make them want to be witches but because there are far better media available, not to mention the fact that I intend media to play a very small role in their lives. A good issue to raise and think on. . .
Report

NameTimberly
Date2007-07-11
MessageOn the sci-fi thing, it is practically impossible to find Christian sci-fi so if anyone knows any authors let me know. smilie
Report

NameTimberly
Date2007-07-11
MessageI have read the books and seen the movies. LeRoy and I have discussed it several times and have come to the conclusion that it is a personal choice. We have friends that are against it, but these same people expose their children to things which we would not expose our children too. Interesting.
I think of the Harry Potter craze in the same way as the beanie babies, Pokemon, etc crazes (which other people might not see my logic here, and that is okay smilie). Life is about choices and I would not choose to make Harry Potter the center of my life or my children's lives. To me it is a book that has captivated people only because people want to be captivated, I think it is a phase that will pass on as the other crazes did, especially now that the last book has been written. I do think the reason why many Christians let their kids read it though is because there are not many Christian authors that captivate children in their writings. There is CS Lewis (which is dated and more metaphor which younger children might have difficulty grasping) and few other authors that write in a style that reaches out and grabs you, especially someone that has read many books and seen many different styles. I have a little trouble finding good authors at the Christian store because they mostly write romance which I enjoyed in my teens but no longer am fascinated by. So writers out there if you want to reach kids pick up your pens, there is a niche that needs to be filled, also write some sci-fi smilie
Report

NameSmandrea
Date2007-07-11
MessageI guess I just feel like if you're not going to watch or read Harry Potter because of the witchcraft in it then you should be just as equal in all things. You shouldn't watch or read Lord of the Rings, The Chronicles of Narnia, The Wizard of Oz. Because if you're not doing it because of God then what makes those things alright to you? It's still witchcraft, it's still evil. Even if it gets beat in the end or is only used by "bad guys" you're still filling your minds with witchcraft.

Why is it only ok to watch witchcraft if it gets beaten in the end? It's still going in your mind. It's still entering your children's minds. Whether it's "good" or "bad" you're putting the same stuff into your mind that you would get out of Harry Potter or any other thing of the sort.
Report

NameTrish
Date2007-07-10
MessageIs Harry Potter vitreous or pure? We go weekly to a mental hospital & do 2 services. Some folks have a chemical problem, others are depressed, a few are demon possessed and oppressed. Some have been visited by "angel like beings" & now claim to be Jesus Christ. What does this have to do with Harry Potter? Spiritual warfare is real. Occasionally during service 1 of these demon possessed people will yell out. Last week a man yelled "Morphin Power Ranger". A couple of weeks ago a woman yelled out "Harry Potter" only to become immediately calm again. You say that is just a toy or a book. Check out the Power Rangers'origin. You can't play with this stuff & not get burned. The Old Testament directly forbids any involvement with witchcraft which is good enough for me. In Deuteronomy it says "There shall not be found among you any one that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an en-chanter, or a witch, or a charmer, or a consulter with familiar spirits, or a wizard, or a necromancer. For all that do these things are an abomination unto the Lord." If they are an abomination unto the Lord why watch or read about them? Instead read Phil 4:8 "whatsoever things are true, whatsoever things are honest, whatsoever things are just, whatsoever things are pure, whatsoever things are lovely, whatsoever things are of good report; if there be any virtue, & if there be any praise, think on these things." If anything Harry Potter is a waste of our time which belongs to God.
Report

Page 252 of 468 << First < 249 250 251 252 253 254 255 > Last >>