| Message | I have a question for anybody who can answer it. It's about the illustrations of "Enterprising Engines" and "Oliver the Western Engine". Duck and Oliver each were given two Auto coaches. For Oliver, notice that in some illustrations he is carrying a single red lamp indicating he's the tail end of the train. Wouldn't it have been standard practice to put Oliver in the middle of his train of auto coaches (as he is equipped for such operation)instead of putting him on the end of the train? He indicates in "Escape" that Isabel is used in push-pull standard pratice. Wouldn't that be hampered by having a second coach between her and Oliver? I can understand about Duck reversing because his class was never equipped for auto coach operation (heck Thomas does the same thing with Annie and Clarabel in the illustrations of "Down the Mine" even though he has no tail lamp)but Oliver just bugs me. Could this just have been because of the illustrators or maybe the practices on Sodor were different? I'm perplexed! Understand this is a question for the illustraions and not of the knowledge of the Reverend. Doubtless he knew GWR practices.
From my limited knowlege of push-pull practice, I think you are right, that to extend a push-pull train, carriages are added at either end with the loco in the middle.
Probably, Peter Edward's illustration in the station of "EE" was meant to show Oliver in full detail without being encumbered by a coach. My guess is that the line was run with no need for push-pull gear in operation, as there was a turntable at each end. That leaves the lights as an anomaly, for sure!
Thanks for your interest and sharp eyesight!
Cheers, Martin |