Sign Guestbook Back to Telmun - The Land of Paradise
| Date | 2007-06-04 |
| Location |  |
| Message | Your article would not pass muster in any international journal of repute. I suggest you get advice on how to present etymological evidence. This is not up to peer-review standards. Your article should stand scrutiny on scientific evidence alone and not rely on emotional pleas. It is a challenge to read this document and gain any logical insight into what you present. Now that you have publicity from the newspaper article (The Hindu), aim for an international peer-reviewed journal. Best of luck to you. |
| Date | 2007-04-15 |
| Location |  |
| Message | Hi,I am the author Samyuktha and I am very happy to read all of your comments on my article, though some of you seem to have doubts, that’s only natural, I'll be glad to answer some of your questions, to begin with, the authenticity of my work is unquestionable as far as proving that the Telugu language existed 4000 years ago, as this evidence can be found in the article "Seafaring Merchants Of Ur" written by A.L. Oppenheim, Oriental Institute, University Of Chicago. The Telugu words that I found in this article are not just my imagination and this very fact is accepted by the historians of Andhra Pradesh, Infact my book on this subject is being published by the Potti Sreeramulu Telugu University-Hyderabad. I have been felicitated numerous times in appreciation of my work, and I am also planning to take a documentary on this very subject on behalf of the Potti Sreeramulu Telugu University. As far as publicizing my work in news papers is concerned, I believe I should achieve my goal in acting upon it that rather in words, which I am glad to say is on the way. For those of you who have supported and encouraged me and my work I thank you from the bottom of my heart and I'll keep my word of fighting for the cause to achieve the ancient status for The Telugu Language. Thank you for all your comments and I hope you'll keep them coming. Have a nice day. O! by the way I am a young woman, and all your comments give strength to carry on my work. Thank You Ms.Samyuktha Kooniah |
| Date | 2007-04-02 |
| Location |  |
| Message | Keep them brainwaves beating mister! Another Entranced reader    |
| Date | 2007-04-01 |
| Location | |
| Message | Hi , the article defintely deserves praise, but the conclusions should rely on some solid proofs not a singular case.i some what agree with one of the comments on this site, seems the author is deepely into glorification of telugu language. good job done but have to reaserch more on the topic. just one suggestion--look at a case critically not with a biased mind... all the best ....... |
| Date | 2007-04-01 |
| Location | |
| Message | Hi , the article defintely deserves praise, but the conclusions should rely on some solid proofs not a singular case.i some what agree with one of the comments on this site, seems the author is deepely into glorification of telugu language. good job done but have to reaserch more on the topic. just one suggestion--look at a case critically not with a biased mind... all the best |
| Date | 2007-02-04 |
| Location | |
| Message | There is no evidence that the Telugu language existed in BC..If you're a real scholar, then you should publicize your article through the newspapers and television. You should also contact reputed scholars like Iravatham Mahadevan and others like him. Please try not to mislead people. Again, publish your paper if you're a genuine scholar. :?. Could you provide some proper proof? |
| Date | 2007-01-13 |
| Location |  |
| Message | Sir its me again , ican i suggest you some thing if you can make some DNA tests of the royal family in andhra pradesh n match them to those royal jewish families may be it can give some evidence, like as you gave some family names which similar in telugu n jews so may be they share the same family traits like color of the skin, or eyes, or DNA may be the same , i dont know if im clear to you or not, if there some scientifical matching between them , then it would be marvelous n beyound wonderful, may be geographically even the land (continents , or countries) might have moved away, there might had been some link islands which might have had linked the lands even more nearer, and it might have possible to travel not from iran to pakidtan to punjab to southwards andhra but may be from sea route directly from iran to india ie, andhra pradesh thank you n all the best |
| Date | 2007-01-13 |
| Location | |
| Message |  respected Siri was astonished amazed wondered n what not when i read this ay n around 11:30 in night, ur laborious work is really far beyond appreciation n encourageable. sir i felt as the whole world is one there is one God whether u say Yehovah, Yellammah,Balaji,Bal,i always thought about these bizzare names like ishkavakula kaalam, satavahana,n the kings names sounded like bizzare telugu, i thought i got ans in your thesis, n also sir, opnce when i was reading Bible, i think its the second book of old testamant , i read how they built a temple for God n the way the pooja carried on in that temple is very similar to the pooja in Hindu temples, it mentions 'Garbha Gudi' the same as we find in Hindu temples. i wish May our andhra government try sincerely in excavading the places u have mentioned n bring to light some more evidences n proof n help in the unification of the world , i mean it sir, all the best Sir |
| Date | 2007-01-03 |
| Location | |
| Message | yes nice article.Good efort. but incredible...... |
| Date | 2007-01-02 |
| Location | |
| Message | Incredibly dumb theory. Just because there appear to be tenuous similarities between the sumerian phonetics with the modern dravidian language does not mean that the Dilmun/Telmun has links to the land of Telgu's. The author has not even compared it with the Mesopotemian language phonetics with dravidian languages say 1000 years ago(when the first instance of the Telgu language has been definitively proven) let alone 2000+ years ago . Indeed, the Indus valley civilisation was a dravidian civilisation and it its links with Mesopotemia were well known, and it is very likey that some words from the Indus Valley Civilisation may have percolated into Mesopotemia. This author seems to have based the theory on an inflated cultural image than any science. |
Page 3 of 4 < 1 2 3 4 >